A little too harsh, imo. Yes, I like that the father took action and made her responsible for her actions, but he could have down it differently. Fact remains, if a child feels loved and wanted and valued, seldom will they act out. This child might again act out in retaliation for the embarrassment she endured. Making someone pay for their actions/bad behavior, is good, and one thing, but knowing and understanding why they committed that behavior is the only way to be assured it or worse won't be repeated.Kids will do things like that for attention sometimes, whether the attention they get is negative or positive. The father seems pretty harsh, so who knows, maybe this was a cry for affection from her father.