Made with Love

Doctor refused to treat girl without vaccinations: Mother

Anto

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2012
Messages
2,467
TRENTON, Ont. — A southeastern Ontario mother has sent a complaint against an emergency room doctor for allegedly refusing to treat her four-year-old daughter.
Brianna Warrhunter took her child to hospital in Trenton Wednesday after a daycare worker noticed an "unexplained rash," the Trenton woman wrote in a complaint she sent to the Ontario Medical Association.

Warrhunter said Dr. Amber Hayward Stewart began to examine her daughter and asked when the girl had her most recent immunizations.
Warrhunter said she told the doctor her daughter didn't have immunizations as she and the father are "conscientious objectors” of immunizations.

“Her tone turned from friendly to rude,” said Warrhunter, alleging the Trenton Memorial Hospital doctor promptly stopped the exam and left the room saying she could not help the girl.
“How were we to go about finding out if she is contagious if no one at emerg will attempt to diagnose her based on the fact that she is not immunized?

I did not seek medical attention for my child for us to be demoralized, judged and lectured like I myself am the child,” said Warrhunter.

“In Canada we have the choice to immunize or not and we choose not to.”

Warrhunter and her daughter left without a diagnosis and went to another hospital.

“The doctor was professional and was aware that my child was not immunized... and assured me it was not contagious and provided a note for my child's daycare,” said Warrhunter.
Quinte Health Care spokeswoman Susan Rowe said she could not speak about the individual case citing patient confidentiality concerns.

“There is no information I can give you from the doctor's perspective or that of other health care provider that might have been involved,” said Rowe.

She did say Quinte Health Care, which operates Trenton Memorial Hospital, does not have a specific policy or protocol for doctors to follow in regards to providing care for unvaccinated children – physicians can make the choice to refuse care for unvaccinated children.

According to the Public Health Agency of Canada, immunizations are not mandatory. However, children in Ontario, New Brunswick and Manitoba require certain vaccines otherwise they may be excluded from going to school during a disease outbreak.

https://www.torontosun.com/2012/07/30/doctor-refused-to-treat-girl-without-vaccinations-mother
 
What the doctor did was unethical. Simple as that, it is not her choice to judge what the parents believe is right or wrong. Damn she is just a kid, not her fault her parents don't have common sense.
 
I heard this in the morning radio station. They gave an example that apparently German measles can be highly contagious etc... and was taking the Doctor's side. But isn't that a risk you have to take in that profession, it does come with the title.
 
I bet you they are Jehovah Witness.

Does that matter really?

The doctor could have been more professional and asked to speak with the parent privately regarding her concerns. The doctor's behaviour could have seriously upset the child.

I have no side in right or wrong here, it does seem unprofessional of the doctor or are we not getting the full story.
 
what was she doing in the ER for a simple rash??

Seems to me that type of question is best answered by the child Pediatrician.

OF course it sounds as if mom and dad have been denying the child preventive medical care.
 
It's not right what the doctor did but it's equally not right if the parents are denying the child preventative health care.
 
As a parent I would be shocked if my child were refused medical attention. I'm not sure I would be able to restrain myself if I believed my child were in danger and a doctor was refusing treatment.
 
What the doctor did was unethical. Simple as that, it is not her choice to judge what the parents believe is right or wrong. Damn she is just a kid, not her fault her parents don't have common sense.

The Doc may have been an ass but it was only unethical if the kid needed treatment, which it didn't and the Doctor probably knew that. Not sure we are getting the full story here.
 
Back
Top Bottom