Made with Love

Muslim Inmates Sue For Islamic Meal Preparation

McGuinty

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
2,033
He has a point.

Abdul Awkal says the prison is not serving his food according to Islamic law and at the same time they provide kosher plates for Jewish prisoners.



Muslim inmates in Ohio decided to sue over their meal preparations. Abdul Awkal says the prison is not serving his food according to Islamic law and at the same time they provide kosher plates for Jewish prisoners. He has filed the suit with another death row inmate, Cornelius Causey, in federal court together alleging a civil rights violation.

The Muslim inmates are served the traditional vegetarian and non-pork meal preparation. However, Awkal said that is not enough. The inmates say the food must be prepared in specific fashion, such as ensuring that an animal is butchered by slitting its throat and draining its blood, to conform with Islamic beliefs.

Awkal alleges that the prison system’s failure to provide the proper preparation for a meal and that is a restraint on his religious freedoms.

“The issue of eating Halal meals is especially important to me because I face a death sentence,” he stated in the court documents. “It is important to me that I follow the requirements of my faith as I approach death.”

Both Awkal and Causey are serving sentences for murder and one of the inmates is being scheduled to be executed in June of next year. He killed his estranged wife and brother-in-law Mahmoud Abdul-Aziz in 1992, in a room in Ohio’s Cuyahoga County Domestic Relations Court.

Causey is currently serving a 15 years to life sentence for murder and aggravated robbery.

Ohio is arguing that it provides the meal preparation as guidelined in the states courts. “The complete restructuring of ODRC’s food service administration and preparation, at a cost of millions to the State of Ohio during fiscal crisis, is at stake,” Ryan Dolan, an assistant attorney general, argued in a court filing.
 

“The issue of eating Halal meals is especially important to me because I face a death sentence,” he stated in the court documents. “It is important to me that I follow the requirements of my faith as I approach death.”

Hmmm he sure didn't follow the rules of his faith in getting himself into trouble now did he?

So I say suck it dude and eat what put in front of you or just plain starve. Come to think of it I rather like that last option.
 

“The issue of eating Halal meals is especially important to me because I face a death sentence,” he stated in the court documents. “It is important to me that I follow the requirements of my faith as I approach death.”

Hmmm he sure didn't follow the rules of his faith in getting himself into trouble now did he?

So I say suck it dude and eat what put in front of you or just plain starve. Come to think of it I rather like that last option.

Even though I agree with you. It still not right that the Jews get it while Muslims don't Just my 2 cents.
 
Even though I agree with you. It still not right that the Jews get it while Muslims don't Just my 2 cents.

Umm how do you know he isn't? "his beef (no pun intended) is that an animal must have it's throat slit and the blood drained..." well, that's how they butcher animals so wtf is his problem?

Sorry, if he wanted his food prepared in a special way, he should have thought about that before breaking the law and being put in a position where he doesn't have a choice.

As for following his faith, for all we know he COULD have been following his faith when he killed his wife since, according to qu'ran: women are to be treated as livestock.
 
I have to totally agree with MB on this one. We need to stop allowing religion of any kind as an excuse to bring crazy beliefs into main stream. Perhaps Allah will understand when he goes to the big mosque in the sky that he was forced to eat north american style and still give him his 30 or 40 virgins..
 
tboy said:
Umm how do you know he isn't? "his beef (no pun intended) is that an animal must have it's throat slit and the blood drained..." well, that's how they butcher animals so wtf is his problem?

Sorry, if he wanted his food prepared in a special way, he should have thought about that before breaking the law and being put in a position where he doesn't have a choice.

As for following his faith, for all we know he COULD have been following his faith when he killed his wife since, according to qu'ran: women are to be treated as livestock.

You are missing the point. Yes, he killed and yes he deserves to be in jail and even hanged for what he did. We also do not know how horrific the jew's doing were either.

There should not be discrimination because of one's religion.
 
You are missing the point. Yes, he killed and yes he deserves to be in jail and even hanged for what he did. We also do not know how horrific the jew's doing were either.

There should not be discrimination because of one's religion.

No matter what the crime no matter how horrific as you say. The inmate has a right of sustenance but that's it. Doesn't matter what religion you are once you cross that threshold all the trapping of outside life are gone for you. And you don't have anybody but yourself to blame.
 
I don't know of any religion that cannot eat bread and butter. Put them all on that and see how they complain about the food disregarding their beliefs next time.

It's not a Taj-ma-prison after all.
 
You are missing the point. Yes, he killed and yes he deserves to be in jail and even hanged for what he did. We also do not know how horrific the jew's doing were either.

There should not be discrimination because of one's religion.

As bosco says, and I wholeheartedly agree, that once you have broken a law serious enough to garner prison time, all your religious freedoms go out the window with your societal freedoms.

The key factor? prison is supposed to punish. If you have specific dietary requirements that affect you deeply, here's a clue: DON'T BREAK THE LAW

Hey, I'm going to start a religion where our "church" donations pay for us to play. Then when I'm in jail, the system has to provide me with hot and cold running hookers.....Sorry, but judaism, islam, catholism, they're all a bunch of hooey........

That's why the problems in the middle east will never be resolved: not only is everyone fighting over whose imaginary friend is better, but they are fighting over the same imaginary friend, just how to properly believe in them! holy crap how fucked are we as a race????
 
As bosco says, and I wholeheartedly agree, that once you have broken a law serious enough to garner prison time, all your religious freedoms go out the window with your societal freedoms.

The key factor? prison is supposed to punish. If you have specific dietary requirements that affect you deeply, here's a clue: DON'T BREAK THE LAW

Hey, I'm going to start a religion where our "church" donations pay for us to play. Then when I'm in jail, the system has to provide me with hot and cold running hookers.....Sorry, but judaism, islam, catholism, they're all a bunch of hooey........

That's why the problems in the middle east will never be resolved: not only is everyone fighting over whose imaginary friend is better, but they are fighting over the same imaginary friend, just how to properly believe in them! holy crap how fucked are we as a race????

I believe the radicals only use religion to bring in the uneducated masses. The culprits deep down are just greedy SOB's and really don't believe in any form of religion.
 
Back
Top Bottom