Made with Love

blurred Lines regarding our industry and human trafficking

Ms.MelodyMerlot

Well-known member
Advertiser
Joined
Jun 7, 2016
Messages
107
i recently attended a lecture at the UofS on sex work and human trafficking in Canada, and particularly, Saskatchewan.
it was open to the public, and was called "neglecting to protect" with Lorna Dornstauder from the RCMP and Don Miekle from Egadz, as well as a lady representing the aboriginal community.


the RCMP lady was mainly focusing on human trafficking, people being brought into the country and forced to work, she talked about BP, and pulled up some girls add from the local BP, and was pointing out signs that this person may be a trafficked person, and honestly, maybe? who knows?
she spoke about how they book appts to meet women who advertise on BP and show up and ask them questions ect.
i admit i was a bit pissed off hen she mentioned meeting "well put together, professional women who refuse to admit they are being pimped" and bemoaned how she just couldn't help those women, and how it was so sad blah blah
and of course they talked about the women who work the streets, and they totally ignored the fact that in Canada, specifically Saskatchewan, women working the streets are usually doing it for ONE reason, drugs.
the "pimps" are more likely drug dealers, and the reason these women are out there is because they have a problem.
(and if people dont like me saying so, well, im sorry, but lets be realistic here.)

she had a long list of problems, zero solutions, except to crack down harder, on all of us.

by the time Done Miekle from Egadz went up to talk i bristling with righteous indignation, and my sister who had came to the lecture with me, was also pretty pissed off, and shes not even in the industry.
anyways, Don, is one of the founders of Egadz youth outreach in Saskatoon, and ironically, i used to be an Egadz kid, Don in fact, used to show up on my behalf in court and get me hauled out whenever i got in trouble in my misguided yet adventurous youth
the problem of minors on the streets, working, is not a new one and the techniques to combat it haven't changed much, again, addiction is glossed over, as more of a symptom of the problem of sex work, than the actual disease driving these kids to the streets.

i bit my lip and held my tongue, because ....hes not the best at public speaking and i respect the man, but good god

when he was done, anoher lady came up and spoke about how indigenous people are more likely to be trafficked in the sex trade, because they are poor and residential school, ect.
of course the addiction and drinking, is just as glossed over and unmentioned, aide to say that sex work drives them to addiction.
okay.
well.

as an escort who has done everything in my power to be as legitimate as i possibly can, who has tried not to be the stereotype, as much as i possibly can, the whole thing was rather insulting.

our industry is blanketed with a one track view, we are victims.

i don't know about the other ladies on here, but like seriously, im pimped by; saskpower, saskenergy, SGI, my car payments, house insurance, an oh lord i do believe my children and even my DOG are living off the avails!! **gasp!!* and the government wants $$ too, for income tax, because i actually report my income (how else can you buy a house or a car ect without proof of income? just how i do it)

but according the Lorna from the RCMP, and people like Don, people like me just don't exist.

i did actually talk to Lorna after the lecture.
and i introduced myself with a smile, as Melody Merlot, at this point im curious if she knows who i am.

she was absolutely shocked , talk about freakin weird! she knew exactly who i was.

apparently, they had been trying to get me to come into Saskatoon for an appt, because they thought maybe i was being trafficked, and pinning me down otherwise is very hard.

i didn't actually even believe her, i thought she was just messing with my head, but nope, she had a copy of my ad from BP printed out and in her briefcase, because during thanksgiving long weekend, they were doing a blitz here.

(i swear to god i am not even making this shit up) needless to say, that was ...my heart was going a million miles a minute, and i was like, yep, thats me alright.
i told her i was absolutely not being pimped and that i was actually really offended by her blatant refusal to admit women like me exist, and that as someone who has tried really hard to be professional, and someone who actually runs my business, as a business, i feel incredibly discriminated against by our government, and people like her, who can meet a professional well put together woman like myself, and not believe us when we say,"hey, this is my business, this is what i do!"
i mean its great that they were worried about me and wanting to heck on me, but what about my ads or website says "trafficked woman being pimped against her will"?

anyways long rant, vent, whatever, its frustrating, how they look at us, with such a narrow lens.

i really wish there was some way to distinguish between "legal professional sex work" and "trafficked women and minors" in the eyes of the law and society

anyways im sorry if i said anything offensive, if i did, sorry didnt mean to

anyways, this has been bothering me ever since and just wanted to let it out :)
xo mel
 
Is there such a way?.

i really wish there was some way to distinguish between "legal professional sex work" and "trafficked women and minors" in the eyes of the law and society
 
Nothing offensive at all Ms. Melody. You are just speaking your mind and you are entitled to.
 
Melody as many have stated, trafficking is conflated and used to push an agenda. I'm curious what was her response to you after you stated and showed how truly together you are and may I add probably make a better living than the RCMP officer.
 
i think she was just as shocked to see me, as i was to see my ad in her briefcase, we did chat a little bit, and honestly, i don't think she knew what to make of me, or the questions i asked, which she had a hard time answering, she did give me her card and said she would love o have a coffee with me? i dunno.....:unknw:

in my opinion there are few things that could be done to regulate and monitor the industry which would make it safer for those working in the industry as well as safer for the public, whom we deal with (our clients)

a few in my mind are;

*provincial licencing instead of the city by city system

* i think it would be beneficial to have health centers set up in the major cities, where we can get monthly or bi monthly health checks, as well as a sit down with a counselor,talk about life and just check in.
and i think that in order to keep your licence current, those health checks should be mandatory

(ok now don't get your knickers in a twist; "whats this sit down with a counselor shit mel?" well, here's the thing. someone who is being trafficked isnt going to be able to come in month after month and lie to a counselor, if she is being exploited or abused, eventually she will feel safe enough to ask for help. this is where we make a concession, to help victims of human trafficking. make sense? also anyone struggling with addiction could find help through this resource as well)(the physical health checks just make sense)

*any adult advertising site selling adspace for canada should require the advertisers licence before they will place an ad - and there should be a way for the site to ensure the licence is valid

*it would be up to bylaw enforcement to continue checking to ensure the girl with the licence is the girl in the ad, and the girl who shows up/ greets them (i think they already do this right?)

*using your licence to post ads for other girls should result in fines or suspension

this should reduce the amount of women trafficked against their will on site like BP.
anyone who would want to continue pimping those women or minors, would have to seek other forums , which the LE can then focus on, leaving us in relative peace

* i don't think working the streets should be legal, its incredibly dangerous, and often fueled by addiction, and when they get picked up (by LE) it should be like, 5 days in jail/detox, and on strike 3, 30 days treatment. (because seriously, if these women (and men) were sober, and healthy, would they choose to work the streets? or get a better job? go to school?
and if those people choose to continue in the industry, then they should be shown how to do it safely, and off the streets

all of the above however, would only be possible if thye no longer criminalize the client

* our clients should not be criminalized in any way shape of form, unless they commit violence towards us.
now i know that the majority of gents out there want nothing to do with, for instance minors, or women being held and sold against their will, but for those that do seek out such things? they should be charged, for sure.

by rights, we are supposed to be reporting our income and paying taxes, right? ok well please show me any other store where the customer can be fined for shopping there?
or maybe a restaurant where anyone caught eating the soup get charged?
how discriminating can you get?! absolute bullshit! but they want us to report our income, right? yeah. i do, but seriously, why should we?
(aside from needing proof of income as a self employed person to get things like mortgage ect)

i mean these are just ideas, from my slightly ADD brain, they makes sense TO ME....it may not make sense to other people - it may even be offensive, and again, not my intention
i just think ...wouldn't it be cool to all collaborate on the laws that WE want to see in place to make our industry a better place?

i personally am really tired of the stereotype, i think its time we rebrand our image, ya know?
if i see another girl in thigh highs, heels and a tiny skirt, staggering down a dark street in another freaking anti sex work poster or ad i think i may scream.
(the street walkers in saskatoon certainly don't dress like that, jeans and hoodies are the go-to apparel, from what i have seen)

the ladies i have met in this industry are hard working professionals, smart, classy, well dressed, well spoken.
am i wrong?
i know there are bad seeds out there, but there are just as many out there who are great at what they do, right?


i would like to hear any ideas others in the industry may have? as to how it could be regulated, and how we could clean up the not so pleasant side of the industry?
gents chime in too, you see us and are the customer, your opinion counts too.
 
i also wanted to say; the anti sex work industry is a huge industry in itself, world wide
these charities and organizations NEED us to be victims, to keep those donations coming in.

in some countries, like kenya for example, its the rescue orgs which are actually pimping girls in some cases, they take them off the streets and turn them into higher class escorts, and they pimp them, yet have websites dedicated to rescuing girls from sex work! its insane! who knows where else this sort of thing happens?

there are former SWs out there crying to the world about how SW needs to be abolished, something they know will never happen, and if you think they don't get paid to make those speeches? bull fucking shit yes they do, they are no longer in the industry yet they continue to exploit it. and im not saying all antis are horrible people or are exploiting the women they claim to help, but where the fuck are the solutions? eh? maybe they need to raise some more money. :unknw:

we cant control what happens in other countries, but we do have a say what happens in ours, or at least we should.
xox
goodnight
mel
 
:YMAPPLAUSE:Thank you Melody for going to that meeting and for sharing your insight and experience. I agree, those of us who CHOOSE to do this of our own free will, certainly are categorized with all the rest. The government does have an agenda and it is to wipe out this industry completely. Backward morals still rule and they don't care if they ruin a lot of lives to save a few. I also agree my only pimp is the government itself, (taxes), power, mortgage co, and yes, lol, my dog as well:) It is sad that we cannot choose the life we want to live, in this supposed democratic country, we have to live the way others think we ought to, and do with our OWN bodies as they wish. Seems we're going backwards instead of forwards.
 
I'm very impressed with you Melody and if the RCMP officer is not it just goes to prove they are just pushing forward with an agenda to abolish prostitution of any kind.
 
there is no point in wiping out the industry, its impossible, we cant let that happen.
we need our own agenda, and perhaps and MLA or MP wiling to take proposed legislation created BY sexworkers to regulate the industry, and push it.
and it needs to be woman MLA or MP, and she needs to be backed by women like you and me Cristy, those of us who are successful and professional, need to step up and fight for our industry.
its just figuring out the whole "how" part .



cristycurves said:
:YMAPPLAUSE:Thank you Melody for going to that meeting and for sharing your insight and experience. I agree, those of us who CHOOSE to do this of our own free will, certainly are categorized with all the rest. The government does have an agenda and it is to wipe out this industry completely. Backward morals still rule and they don't care if they ruin a lot of lives to save a few. I also agree my only pimp is the government itself, (taxes), power, mortgage co, and yes, lol, my dog as well:) It is sad that we cannot choose the life we want to live, in this supposed democratic country, we have to live the way others think we ought to, and do with our OWN bodies as they wish. Seems we're going backwards instead of forwards.
 
I would vote for you in a political position in a heartbeat Melody!:YMAPPLAUSE:
 
voting with the big head or the little head? lol xoxox thank you darling

Analme said:
I would vote for you in a political position in a heartbeat Melody!:YMAPPLAUSE:
 
thank you :) i dont think the propaganda they are taught includes a chapter on women like me, and im fairly certain im the last person she expected to show up there lol hopefully i opened her eyes in some small way


Madman said:
I'm very impressed with you Melody and if the RCMP officer is not it just goes to prove they are just pushing forward with an agenda to abolish prostitution of any kind.
 
Love the idea of license, unfortunately that can't happen right now because it isn't a legal business.

I totally agree that the government should focus on street prostitution, it is a different world for the most part.

I believe one way to target the trafficked women is by making it a licensed business for each individual woman. Impose stiff fines for those who do not comply, this would be the cities jurisdiction. I see a problem with that, many women do not want their name being recorded as a prostitute, nor do they want the CRA sniffin their asses.
 
unfortunately i do not posses a degree in law or political science...but then again...look at our PM, so maybe i do have a chance....

Beef Jerky said:
I am with the gang. Get into politics Ms. Merlot, you will win by a landslide.
 
jeg said:
Love the idea of license, unfortunately that can't happen right now because it isn't a legal business. that's not entirely true; its half way legal, my end, the business end is legal, and taxable, and its very easy to run it "as a business", and any ladies who would want help figuring out how to do that should contact me, its so easy, also, city licences already exist, provincial would just make things a lot easier.

I totally agree that the government should focus on street prostitution, it is a different world for the most part.

I believe one way to target the trafficked women is by making it a licensed business for each individual woman. Impose stiff fines for those who do not comply, this would be the cities jurisdiction. I see a problem with that, many women do not want their name being recorded as a prostitute, nor do they want the CRA sniffin their asses.[/QUOTE]
i absolutely agree with the first part, however, i dont think it should be recorded as "prostitute", "adult service provider" is the more likely term, and honestly, as an adult service provider myself, i have zero shame associated to what i do for a living.

that's something we all have to find a way to deal with (the stigma), but my personal philosophy is this;

"God created me perfectly, and i am who i am supposed to be, this is what i am good at, what i am drawn to, and what i have spent almost half my life doing one way or another. i accept and love myself for who i am, and i am grateful for the interactions i have with the people i meet, i don't believe in coincidence, the people we come in contact with, are put in our paths for a reason, we all have our chances to be angels, to give grace, kindness, benevolence, to uplift, and to encourage, and i try to take those opportunities whenever i can, because its really good karma. i do what i do with pride, integrity and honor, and because of that, i feel no shame in what i do."


once you can get to that Zen point of self acceptance, you know who you are, and others negative opinions about your lifestyle don't matter very much.

if you are in this industry, either its a huge secret, or no secret at all.

and for those who are keeping it this huge secret, they are opening the door for extortion, blackmail, there are those who will make a point in figuring out who you are and they will try to extort you (been there, had that happen) and half the time, due to technology, you wont even know who's behind it
so then you have a choice, do i give in to fear and start paying these people to keep it a secret? in my case, i was told my name, my ex husbands name, where he worked, where we lived and where my kids went to school.
they wanted $1000/week, or everyone would know.
the stress was unreal, the tight feeling in your chest of panic setting in....i cant even begin to describe what an awful feeling it was

within 24 hours, anyone who was important to me knew what i was doing for a living
on MY terms
and you know what? my family not only still loves me, but they have grown to respect what im doing with my life.
those who couldnt handle it, didnt matter as much as i thought they would.

not long after, they contacted me again, threatening to send my info to the CRA for tax evasion.

the next day, i hired an accountant, obtained a GST#, and started claiming my income.
for the last 3 years, i have reported my income, and i have 3 years worth of tax returns now as a sole proprietor small business owner, and if you have a good accountant, its really not hard to keep your net income a lot lower than your gross, because we have a lot of deductible expenses.

so thanks to my psycho would be extortionist, i was forced to out myself and learn how to run my business as a business.
and you know what? i dont mind.
sometimes, a house must be burt before you rebuild a nice new one.

paying taxes isnt really that hard or scary, honest to god.




 
Prim0 said:
I don't think you can wipe out trafficking. Think about it....you make prostitution completely illegal...everywhere. What happens?.....does prostitution stop? Not at all.

Unfortunately, the right for two people to get together and freely exchange services for payment isn't something everyone agrees with. For all of their talk about free markets, most on the right see prostitution as a sin. And for all of the talk about staying out of people's bedrooms, the left see's it as a sin as well. So anyone who supports the freedom is in a small minority. Even if more people support it, they aren't willing to go on the record and say so. It's just to embarrassing for them. So what can really be done?

I like what was said above about licensing with required "checkups". That way a lady could communicate with authorities without any trafficker being their to influence her. The thing is, most people don't trust that the authorities would be able to protect them. Imagine a girl comes in and says that yes, some gang is forcing her to do this and has threatened her family if she talks. Authorities have to follow rules about this and it takes too long and in the end, the girl is on her own. Will the government pay to put her in the equivalent of a witness protection program? Where does that money come from? And if the traffickers are part of an organization large enough, they could find her and do whatever.
dont those anti sex work human trafficking people excel at fundraising? wow wouldnt it be cool if funds raised actually went to helping women in that sort of situation?!
i know, its a crazy idea.
some head of some charity wont like it at all, especialy if that means
her cut is smaller
.
It's a tough situation and I'm not at a level of intelligence to figure it out. Everyone should be free to do as they will with nobody else forcing them to do or not do. But the ability to enforce that may be beyond our society.

:wink2: ill say no more :)
 
Back
Top Bottom