Made with Love

Why is the Confederate flag still there???

peace

Reviewer
Joined
Dec 23, 2010
Messages
29,067
I am going to steal one of many Fang's quotes....for the love of GOD, please get rid of or burn the damn flag......and how do you feel about it?


[h=1]Charleston blacks, whites unite, but remain divided on flag[/h]
charleston1.jpg.size.xxlarge.letterbox.jpg
David Goldman / The Associated Press
Barbara Lloyd, of Charleston, S.C., cries Friday as she joins hands with mourners during the singing of "We Shall Overcome" at a memorial service for the victims of the shooting at Emanuel AME Church in Charleston on Wednesday night.





By: Daniel Dale Washington Bureau, Published on Fri Jun 19 2015








CHARLESTON, S.C.—The killer tried to divide Charleston’s communities, the mayor said, but instead brought them together.

This was not mere mayor-speak. The day after a white man was arrested for the murder of nine members of a black church, Joe Riley’s Bible Belt city was the picture of racial unity. Right behind him, in front of the church, blacks and whites joined hands in public prayer, offered each other consoling hugs, left bouquets side by side.

Then they were asked about the Confederate battle flag.

“It should be burned. It should be burned,” said Janie Jackson-McClinton, a 51-year-old black woman.

“I don’t know how they look at it from their side. But from our side, it’s just part of the heritage,” said Pam Ridgway, a 63-year-old white woman.

“Racism. Slavery,” said Candice White, a 41-year-old black woman.

“It doesn’t just represent hatred or racism,” said Scott West, a 26-year-old white man. “It also represents the South.”

Dylann Storm Roof, the man accused of the murders, was photographed posing in front of a car with a Confederate flag decal on its licence plate. The photo, and the alleged racial motive for the violence, has reignited one of South Carolina’s most bitter and long-running debates: whether the flag should continue to fly at the state capitol in Columbia.


“Some will assert that the Confederate flag is merely a symbol of years gone by,” Cornell William Brooks, president of the NAACP, said at a Charleston news conference on Friday. “A symbol of heritage and not hate. But where we see that symbol lifted up as an emblem of hate, as a tool of hate, as an inspiration for hate, as an inspiration for violence, that symbol has to come down.”

The flag was used by the Civil War’s pro-slavery South. South Carolina was the first state to secede from the Union. The state government raised the red, blue and white flag again in 1961 — the centennial of the Civil War, but also, not coincidentally, the middle of the civil rights movement.

The government came up with a “compromise” in 2000: the flag would be removed from the capitol dome and hung instead at a memorial to Confederate soldiers. But its sanctioned presence anywhere on state grounds is seen by many blacks as an affront.

“Anything that has anything to do with prejudices and segregation, I have a concern about,” said Catherine Harrington, 59, the sister of Myra Thompson, one of the murder victims. “I think now we should be able to move forward.”

The flag was particularly conspicuous on Thursday. Other flags were lowered to half-staff. The Confederate flag remained at its regular height. Under the compromise law, it cannot be lowered.

On Friday, Democratic state legislators said they would push to have the flag permanently removed. They face long odds. The Republican governor, Nikki Haley, has repeatedly defended the flag. U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham, a Republican presidential candidate, called it “part of who we are.”

South Carolina’s blacks and Democrats overwhelmingly oppose the flag. But its whites and Republicans overwhelmingly support it, arguing that it honours the South’s war dead without glorifying slavery. White Republicans dominate state politics.

“They’re not ready for change yet. I don’t see it in my generation. I don’t see it in my kids’ generation,” said Rasheed Ali, a 57-year-old NAACP member. “This is a Republican stronghold. And the Republicans live and die for the Confederacy, for the most part.”

One Republican, State Rep. Doug Brannon, announced Friday night that he plans to introduce a bill to remove the flag. Brannon said he wants to honour his murdered friend Clementa Pinckney, a Democratic state senator and the pastor of the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church.

Hundreds of whites visited the memorial outside the church earlier Friday to express sympathy and solidarity, some of them sobbing and shaking. Debra and Terry Flowers, bed-and-breakfast owners who live a block away, left a card.

Debra, 59, rolled her eyes when told of the renewed effort to get the flag taken down.

“Can we just leave it alone?” she said. “It wasn’t something we did. Unfortunately, our ancestors — but we can’t take responsibility.”

Sherry Ramsey, 54, arrived at the church with a hand-coloured sign that said “Love Thy Neighbor.” She defended the flag passionately.

“A lot of people got killed during that war. And that’s kind of in honour of them. So people shouldn’t look at it as a racism flag,” she said.

Then, haltingly, she began to reconsider.

“Even though that’s kind of why they were fighting. I don’t know. I’m confused about it. It’s something that wasn’t even worth fighting for. I mean, it was worth fighting for, and thank God we did fight for it. But too many people do see it as symbolic of slavery and all.

“So maybe they should take it down. I don’t know.”
 
That is a question that has been asked for a very long time.

The only people actually qualified to ask and answer that question are the citizens of South Carolina.
 
I disagree.
does not matter

It is a question and States rights and only that State can decide the issue.

If for some reason you disagree, don't live there.

I find the display repugnant. But I support the fact as a State they can display it.
 
It's time they retire the old flag that symbolizes white supremacy. Time to grow up.
There is an idiot that lives a block over from me and has that flag in his front yard....what a looser.
If you respect freedom, this flag represents the opposite of that.

https://www.vox.com/2015/6/20/8818093/confederate-flag-south-carolina-charleston-shooting

the Flag is a symbol of the "Old South" should have been retired in 1865.

Many in the South will tell you it is flown as a reminder of the Fight for States Rights, when we in the North refer to as the Civil War.

I find that a flag does not incite anything but rather the beliefs the individual will incite those same beliefs in others, who are open to it.

If you think that by out-lawing an Outdated Flag you will begin to put hatred to rest you better think again.
 
I highly doubt a piece of cloth could incite any violence or hatred of any kind.

No that's just a plain old human nature thing in my books.

Having said that lets leave it up to the good citizens and their elected officials to decide.
 
Personally, I don't buy the argument that it is historically significant in ways other than being a symbol for racism and the pro-slavery states prior to the war.

Every racist organization in that part of the world uses it. Between its current popularity with those groups and its history how can anybody suggest that there is a positive here that outweighs the negative. Worked in that part of the world a few years back and saw unspeakable blatant acts of racism being justified and defended by people who had that flag plastered all over their cars, trucks, heavy machinery, clothes, homes, etc. It is a huge part of the racist culture and having government and the general public acknowledge this fact is a huge step forward in getting at the bigger problem - racist culture.

Unfortunately, attacking this symbol of racism will probably draw more of the crazies out of the shadows and there will probably be more bloodshed.
 
The cloth itself, no. It's what it stands for in people's minds.

Wanna show a few peopl a nazi flag and ask them their opinions?

Well the Swastika is actually a sacred symbol in Hinduism and Buddhism. And was for centuries until a certain madman perverted it to mean something else.

I guess my point OG is that if that flag was outlawed the hatred groups would just come up with another symbol to take it's place.

It's a messy situation no matter how you look at it.
 
Well the Swastika is actually a sacred symbol in Hinduism and Buddhism. And was for centuries until a certain madman perverted it to mean something else.

I guess my point OG is that if that flag was outlawed the hatred groups would just come up with another symbol to take it's place.

It's a messy situation no matter how you look at it.

On the latter point, I completely agree.

Having lived in Asia for many years, it was always interesting to walk by a temple in Vietnam that had the swastika all over it. Whether we like it or not, we've been conditioned to associate the swastika with Naziism. And while the flag and symbol are powerless, the hate that the symbol generates in some people is real. It makes no sense to intelligent people, but then, most of those idiots don't fall into that category.

I agree banning any flag or symbol is stupid; if anything it stengthens the fervor. Look at the Confederate Flag. It doesn't mean slavery, or anything like that, but a union of states for common economic purposes. Slavery was one nasty development in those states' history, but slavery existed before and after. I don't associate the Confederate flag with slavery, just a group of southern states being proud of themselves.
 
GOOD NEWS!! SC Govenor Nikki Haley gave a press conference today, surrounded by an impressive group of supporters, and announced that the confederate battle flag will be removed from the capitol grounds, saying, “We are not going to allow this symbol to divide us any longer. The fact that people are choosing to use it as a sign of hate is something we cannot stand.”:clapping2::clapping2::clapping2:
 
GOOD NEWS!! SC Govenor Nikki Haley gave a press conference today, surrounded by an impressive group of supporters, and announced that the confederate battle flag will be removed from the capitol grounds, saying, “We are not going to allow this symbol to divide us any longer. The fact that people are choosing to use it as a sign of hate is something we cannot stand.”:clapping2::clapping2::clapping2:



I'm glad to see some politicians coming around on this. But I'm not sure the Governor has the authority to make the decision, I think it's the Legislature.

I do think the flag will ultimately be removed from State property, but not without a fight.
 
I agree banning any flag or symbol is stupid; if anything it stengthens the fervor. Look at the Confederate Flag. It doesn't mean slavery, or anything like that, but a union of states for common economic purposes. Slavery was one nasty development in those states' history, but slavery existed before and after. I don't associate the Confederate flag with slavery, just a group of southern states being proud of themselves.


I doubt anyone seriously expects to get the Confederate flag banned. The effort is to have it removed from Capitol property.

I can understand how a Canadian who has spent significant time in Asia wouldn't equate the flag with slavery. But because the Confederate economy was completely dependent on the cotton industry, the biggest common economic purpose the southern states shared was the need to keep slavery legal.

So I'm sure you can see how others make the clear and obvious connection between the symbolism of that flag and slavery.


Gntlmn said:
Personally, I don't buy the argument that it is historically significant in ways other than being a symbol for racism and the pro-slavery states prior to the war.

Every racist organization in that part of the world uses it. Between its current popularity with those groups and its history how can anybody suggest that there is a positive here that outweighs the negative. Worked in that part of the world a few years back and saw unspeakable blatant acts of racism being justified and defended by people who had that flag plastered all over their cars, trucks, heavy machinery, clothes, homes, etc. It is a huge part of the racist culture and having government and the general public acknowledge this fact is a huge step forward in getting at the bigger problem - racist culture.

Unfortunately, attacking this symbol of racism will probably draw more of the crazies out of the shadows and there will probably be more bloodshed.

This.

written from my home in the southern US
 
I am going to steal one of many Fang's quotes....for the love of GOD, please get rid of or burn the damn flag......and how do you feel about it?

Worst imitation of me EVER!

This topic is very near and dear to me. One of my best friends who I met in college in the U.S. lives in Charleston. We have developed such a tight friendship that I visit him regularly every year. I've been going to Charleston and the surrounding areas including Hilton Head for about 15 years now and absolutely adore the place and the people that live that live there. They are some of the kindest people that I've ever encountered. The confederate flag is a complicated issue for some and clear cut for others.

After the American Civil war that flag disappeared. It was still around however it was not displayed with the pride and eagerness that it is today. That changed during the 1960's and the civil rights movement. The resurgence of the flag coincided with civil liberties march by the blacks. Since then it has been a fixture in some parts of the south. There is NO question in my mind and in the minds of many who live in Charleston what that flag represents. It was brought out of retirement by those who longed for a time passed to force their will on others they believed were not worthy. It was brought out of retirement as a show of force and to intimidate those who's only crime was to want the rights and freedoms guaranteed to them by the Constitution.

That flag needs to go.
 
The confederate flag is a complicated issue for some and clear cut for others.

This ^^^^

I am reminded of the issue of Canada's own dilemma concerning the people of Quebec defined as a 'distinct society' within the Canadian Confederation, and the flying of the Provincial Flag of Quebec in lieu of the Canadian National Flag by separatists seeking the secession of the province from the rest of Canada.
 
Back
Top Bottom