Any facility participating in rehabilitating a bully in this manner, would not give them total unsupervised time taking care of people. It would be part of a supervised structured program. Taking someone out of their element and teaching them responsibility is a powerful personality changer. But if you believe change can only be effected through confrontation, well, there we differ. Trying to teach a bully through domination, is just setting the example that it is ok to bully, as long as you're the stronger.
The thing I think you miss is the fact that THE LAW and society is in fact stronger (or should be) that you. It is what keeps the wolves at bay. I mean, think about it: society has politicians that make laws that govern the way we are supposed to treat each other. Break those laws and you're supposed to be punished (not coddled) for it.
Yes, our parents taught us that stealing is wrong. If our parents didn't do that, it is the law that is going to have to take over. If a person commits a violent crime against another child, they need to learn that causing someone physical pain has ramifications. I think suspension is useless, all that does is give them a vacation ie: a reward for their actions.
As for supervised care in various institutions. Hell, employees commit atrocities to the infirm as it is, so even they aren't supervised that well. Now if you want to have them work there, have them cleaning bedpans, mopping the floor, etc. Do NOT put them in a position to be in contact with those that are (as player said) in a weakened state. That just teaches them that there are always more victims if you look for them.
I tell you, it's not on anymore but the scared straight program works and believe me, the inmates taking part in the program do NOT coddle the kids.
(and yes, no matter what, there are always stronger, meaner, badder people out there. Teaching a kid that at an early age will make them realize that maybe the next kid he bullies, will be one of those......) The thing that is prevalent now? Handguns. Those are the big equalizer.
I will tell you this: the two bullies that made my grade 7 and 8 a living hell? Wouldn't be alive today if I had access to a gun. The cops didn't do anything, the school didn't do anything constructive. When the cops were contacted, they investigated, sure, the two came from a troubled home. BFD. They should have been a) expelled and b) arrested if they came anywhere near me but the school and the police took Bliss's stance and said "they deserve understanding blah blah blah. So instead of MY rights to a safe and happy school being protected, THEIR right to make my life hell was protected.......