Now here's an idea...

[T.A.F.K.A. Prince]

I was searching through the incall thread, and a light bulb flashed above my head.

What if every girl who has a review had her own thread and also a rating system for looks, service and attitude? Like a scale from 1 (lowest) to 10 (highest).

Any person could place a formal review but those less inclined could contribute anonymously by just using the number scale.

This does beg the question, how do we eliminate shills? The number scale would have to be locked to advertisers (agency and indies). Maybe have a system where only screened members may vote?

If this was to work I honestly believe this site would have more traffic and be greater than it's competitors in this city.

 

[Ozzie]

Like the idea.

 

[Senor Gomes]

Hmmmmmm

 

[DannyDeVito]

How can one not agree with Prince :-Cool/"

I like that idea.

 

[Macho Man]

Prince for Mod
Prince for Mod
Prince for Mod

 

[Morpheus]

Prince, allowing anonymous feedback is tricky. It may allow for more participation, but as you pointed out, it may allow for excessive positive or negative responses. Shilling is not the only bad side effect, negative trolling would also have to be monitored. It's a good idea, it's implementation might be tricky. We will discuss it.
Keep the suggestions coming, let us know if anyone has ways of improving the site.

 

[T.A.F.K.A. Prince]

Prince, allowing anonymous feedback is tricky. It may allow for more participation, but as you pointed out, it may allow for excessive positive or negative responses. Shilling is not the only bad side effect, negative trolling would also have to be monitored. It's a good idea, it's implementation might be tricky. We will discuss it.

This is why I mentioned that the only people that can input numbers on the scale for beauty/attitude/service would be trusted people on this site. Those that want to contribute to the scale would need to be screened, possibly having reviewed before.

Posting a regular review would be open for anyone and not be anonymous. And if say, Senor Gomes was to see Candy Cane, but didn't feel like posting a full review of her, he could contribute another way by inputting his ratings for beauty/attitude and service.

Thanks for considering!

 

[Maurice Boscorelli]

Me thinks The Prince could be onto something here.

 

[Hitter]

Excellent idea. I repeat with my favs plus see many well reviewed SP that I have a hard time writing a review because there isn't anything new I can add.

Does Sinful Sophia need a new review?. This woman is tops but what more can I add that 100 members have already said?.

 

[Romance]

Not all readers or reviewers are into rating or scaling system. Other than problems that prince and mods mentioned, it gives the feeling of buying an online product rather than selecting a companion for an hour or so. I prefer to make my decision based on individual reviews with variety of styles.

 

[Brocklee]

I am the shy type and would welcome this new format.

 

[T.A.F.K.A. Prince]

Not all readers or reviewers are into rating or scaling system. Other than problems that prince and mods mentioned, it gives the feeling of buying an online product rather than selecting a companion for an hour or so. I prefer to make my decision based on individual reviews with variety of styles.

I agree Romance, I make my decisions based on written reviews, too. I just want it to be clear that no one has to feel pressured to use a rating or scaling system, it's there if they choose to use it. Some people are not into writing a review (for their own personal reasons) so a scaling system gives them the option to contribute to this board in a way that's quick, simple and anonymous. If they choose to avoid numbers, and just write a simple review, they can do that instead.

Last thing that I want is for written reviews to stop. What I would hope would come from this is more contribution from members of this board. We could go from having 7 or 8 written reviews of Carmen at Mirage, to 7 or 8 written reviews and 43 users voting on the scaling system for those three traits I mentioned; beauty, service and attitude.

 

[Jackson]

I agree Romance, I make my decisions based on written reviews, too. I just want it to be clear that no one has to feel pressured to use a rating or scaling system, it's there if they choose to use it. Some people are not into writing a review (for their own personal reasons) so a scaling system gives them the option to contribute to this board in a way that's quick, simple and anonymous. If they choose to avoid numbers, and just write a simple review, they can do that instead.

Last thing that I want is for written reviews to stop. What I would hope would come from this is more contribution from members of this board. We could go from having 7 or 8 written reviews of Carmen at Mirage, to 7 or 8 written reviews and 43 users voting on the scaling system for those three traits I mentioned; beauty, service and attitude.

Hope the mods find a good medium on this idea. I am all for it.

 

[Morpheus]

It is being considered on how best to implement this mechanism.

 

[Patron]

I am the shy type and would welcome this new format.

Gets my vote.

 

[Prick]

Hurry up before they steal your idea.